Umarex vs Tanaka Works: airsoft replicas compared
Umarex has 141 replicas in the database, Tanaka Works has 134. Here is how they compare by category, power, weight and Italy's 1 joule limit.
| Umarex | Tanaka Works | |
|---|---|---|
| Replicas in database | 141 | 134 |
| From official source | 4% | 0% |
| Within 1 J | 36% | 96% |
| Median FPS | 345 | 280 |
| Median rifle weight | 3,070 g | 3,350 g |
| Median pistol weight | 740 g | 750 g |
| Main types | GBB (gas blowback) 82, CO2 27, AEG (electric) 21 | Gas NBB (non-blowback) 113, GBB (gas blowback) 18, Spring 3 |
Comparison of database figures, not a quality verdict. Percentages for the 1 J limit count only replicas with an energy value.
Assault rifles & carbines
Umarex (8)
- G28 GBB Airsoft Rifle DX - Tan (by VFC) 1.80 J
- IWI Tavor SAR GBBR (by KWA) 1.80 J
- G28 AEG Airsoft Rifle DX - Black (by VFC) 1.72 J
- G28 AEG Airsoft Rifle DX - Tan (by VFC) 1.72 J
- G28 DMR GBB Airsoft Rifle - Tan (by VFC) 1.68 J
- HK416D GBB Gen 3 Airsoft Rifle (by VFC) 1.64 J
- G3A3 GBB Airsoft Rifle (by VFC) 1.49 J
- GRS Custom HK417 Limited Benghazi Edition GBBR V2 (by VFC) 1.49 J
Tanaka Works (3)
SMGs
Umarex (8)
- MP5A5 Airsoft AEG Rifle - Zinc DieCasting Version (by VFC) 1.49 J
- MP5SD3 Early Type Airsoft SMG GBB V2 (by VFC) 1.49 J
- / VFC MP7A1 Airsoft AEG SMG (Lite Version) 1.34 J
- MP40 Legends CO2 Airsoft Version (by WinGun) 1.34 J
- MP5A4 AEG (by VFC) 1.34 J
- MP5A4 AEG Airsoft Rifle (by VFC) 1.34 J
- MP5A5 AEG (by VFC) 1.34 J
- MP5A5 Gen 2 GBBR Airsoft (by VFC) 1.34 J
Tanaka Works (0)
- –
DMR & sniper rifles
Umarex (1)
Tanaka Works (8)
- M40A1 Black - Gas Version 1.64 J
- M700 A.I.C.S. Coverd Snyper with 3-9x40mm Scope & High Mount Rings 1.45 J
- M700 A.I.C.S. Covered Snyper with 3-9x40mm Scope & High Mount Rings 1.45 J
- M40A1 USMC Wood Stock Sniper Airsoft Classic Rifle (Spring Power) 1.14 J
- M700 A.I.C.S. Green 24 inch Cartridge Shell Ejecting Type 1.14 J
- USMC M40A1 (Cartridge Shell Ejecting Type 1.14 J
- M40A1 Black (Cartridge Type Version 2) - Gas Version 0.89 J
- M40A1 Midnight Gold (Gas Bolt Action) 0.75 J
Light machine guns
Umarex (1)
- / VFC MG4 LMG Airsoft AEG 1.01 J
Tanaka Works (0)
- –
Pistols
Umarex (8)
- Revolver SAA .45 CO2 Metal (6mm, Nickel Pearl) (by WinGun) 1.72 J
- Revolver SAA .45 CO2 Revolver Metal (6mm, Antique Black) - Cowboy Police Version (by WinGun) 1.72 J
- Revolver SAA .45 CO2 Revolver Metal (6mm, Nickel Pearl) - Cowboy Police Version (by WinGun) 1.72 J
- SAA .45 Co2 (6mm Version) Metal Revolver - Cowboy Police Version (Blue / Brown) (by WinGun) 1.72 J
- SAA .45 Co2 (GK Custom 6mm Version) Metal Revolver (Antique Black) (by WinGun) 1.72 J
- SAA .45 Co2 (GK Custom 6mm Version) Metal Revolver (Blue / Brown) - Cowboy Police Version (by WinGun) 1.72 J
- Revolver SAA Legends ACE 6mm Weathered Version 1.49 J
- BERETTA M96A1 - 6mm CO2 Airsoft Pistol (Black) (by KWC) 1.27 J
Tanaka Works (8)
- SIG P220 IC Japan Ground Self Defence Force Heavy Weight Green Gas Airsoft Pistol 0.98 J
- M36 .38 Special Chiefs Special 2 Inch Version 2 - Black Heavy Weight 0.95 J
- S&W M60 Gas Revolver Ver. 2.1 (2inch) Stainless Finish 0.89 J
- S&W M60 Gas Revolver Ver. 2.1 (3inch) Stainless Finish 0.89 J
- Smith & Wesson M60 Lady Smith 2 inch (Stainless ABS) 0.89 J
- SW M36 Lady Smith 2 inch (Steel version) 0.89 J
- Browning Hi-Power Canadian GBB Airsoft Pistol 0.84 J
- Browning Hi-Power MK III Stainless GBB Airsoft Pistol 0.84 J
More comparisons
Tokyo Marui vs UmarexTokyo Marui vs Tanaka WorksARES vs UmarexARES vs Tanaka WorksASG vs UmarexASG vs Tanaka WorksVFC vs UmarexVFC vs Tanaka WorksEMG vs UmarexEMG vs Tanaka WorksG&G vs UmarexG&G vs Tanaka Works